What makes an ore deposit

Almost every metal is spread thinly through ordinary rock. An ore deposit is a rare place where nature has concentrated it enough, and in a big enough pile, that digging it up pays.

By the end of this module, you will be able to
  • Explain why "ore" is an economic word, not just a geological one
  • Tell a mineral, an ore mineral and gangue apart
  • Explain concentration factors: how far nature has to enrich each metal
  • Work with grade, tonnage, cut-off grade and contained metal, as in the worked example
  • Use the source–transport–trap framework that runs through the next three modules
  • Explain what critical minerals are and why the energy transition needs them, and describe India's push to secure them

Ore is an economic idea

Copper is everywhere. A random shovel of granite, basalt or soil contains some. So does seawater. What is rare is copper that is concentrated enough to be worth extracting. Geologists call that rock ore: rock from which one or more metals or minerals can be mined, processed and sold at a profit.

That last phrase matters. Whether a rock counts as ore depends on the metal price, the cost of energy and labour, the mining and processing technology available, how far the deposit is from a road, railway or port, and whether communities and regulators will allow a mine. The same rock can be ore one decade and waste the next. In the early 1900s, two new methods together turned huge, low-grade copper bodies in the Americas into ore: digging whole hillsides in bulk from open pits with steam shovels, and a separation technique called froth flotation. That is why the field is called economic geology.

Three words come up constantly:

Building block

Mineral

Any naturally occurring crystal with a fixed chemical recipe, as in Minerals & lithology. Quartz, feldspar and olivine are minerals.

The valuable part

Ore mineral

The mineral that actually holds the metal you want. Copper usually sits in chalcopyrite (CuFeS2), zinc in sphalerite (ZnS), lead in galena (PbS) and chromium in chromite.

The rest

Gangue

Pronounced "gang". The worthless minerals the ore mineral is mixed with, typically quartz, feldspar, calcite and clays. In most base- and precious-metal ores, gangue is well over 95% of the rock.

Ore, ~0.5% Cu (magnified) Crush, grind and float Concentrate ~25–30% Cu ~2% of the mass Tailings ~98% of the mass mostly gangue
Ore mineral (chalcopyrite)QuartzFeldsparQuartz and feldspar are gangue
A copper ore is mostly gangue. A mill crushes it fine enough to free the ore-mineral grains, then floats them off as a concentrate that goes to a smelter. Everything else leaves as finely ground tailings, stored in a dam. The two heaps are drawn to scale by mass: about 50 tonnes of tailings for every tonne of concentrate. (Inside the circle, grain sizes and the share of chalcopyrite are exaggerated so you can see them.)

How much does nature have to concentrate a metal?

Each element has an average abundance in the continental crust. Divide a typical ore grade by that average and you get the concentration factor: how many times richer than ordinary rock an ore has to be. It tells you how special the geological process must have been.

~60 ppmcopper in average continental crust (parts per million)
~0.5%copper in a typical large porphyry ore (5,000 ppm)
~80×enrichment nature had to achieve for a 0.5% porphyry
Aluminium~8% → 20–30% ~3–4× Iron~5% → 30–65% ~6–13× Copper~60 ppm → 0.5–1% ~80–170× Nickel~80 ppm → 1–2% ~125–250× Lithium~20 ppm → 0.5–0.7% ~250–350× Gold~0.004 ppm → 1–5 g/t ~250–1,250× Zinc~70 ppm → 5–10% ~700–1,400× 1×10×100×1,000×10,000× Concentration factor (log scale)
How far nature has to enrich each metal to make a typical ore. Each bar reaches the middle of the range; the thin whisker under it spans the range. The small grey text under each name is average crust → typical ore grade. Note the log scale: each gridline is ten times the one before.
Show the numbers as a table
MetalAverage crustTypical ore gradeConcentration factor
Aluminium~8%~20–30% (bauxite)~3–4×
Iron~5%~30–65%~6–13×
Copper~60 ppm~0.5–1%~80–170×
Nickel~80 ppm~1–2%~125–250×
Lithium~20 ppm~0.5–0.7% (hard-rock ore)~250–350×
Gold~0.004 ppm~1–5 g/t~250–1,250×
Zinc~70 ppm~5–10%~700–1,400×

All figures are rounded. Published crustal averages differ between sources, by up to a factor of two or three for copper and gold. We use older textbook values; newer estimates would make the copper and gold factors two to three times larger. One unit to know: g/t (grams per tonne) is the same as ppm, and is how gold, silver and platinum grades are quoted. Notice the pattern. Aluminium and iron are so common that a modest natural upgrade is enough. Gold and zinc need the most concentration of the metals shown, and much more of the planet's gold is still locked in ordinary rock than will ever be mined.

Grade, tonnage and the cut-off

Two numbers describe any deposit. Grade is the concentration of the valuable metal: % for base metals, g/t for precious metals. Tonnage is how much ore there is, usually in millions of tonnes (Mt). Multiply them and you get the contained metal, the total amount of metal in the ground.

Where you draw the edge of the ore body is a choice. Ore grade usually fades gradually into waste rock. The cut-off grade is the lowest grade that is worth sending to the mill rather than the waste dump. Raise the cut-off and you get fewer tonnes of richer ore. Lower it and you get more tonnes of poorer ore. Mines recalculate it as prices and costs change. The break-even cut-off is simply the grade at which the copper in a tonne of rock just pays for mining and processing that tonne.

Worked example

Contained metal. A copper deposit has 200 Mt of ore at 0.6% Cu. Contained copper = 200,000,000 t × 0.006 = 1.2 million tonnes. If the mill recovers about 88% of it, about 1.05 Mt of copper can actually be sold.

Cut-off grade. Say mining and processing one tonne of ore costs US$15, copper sells for about US$9 per kg, and recovery is 88%. One tonne at 1% Cu holds 10 kg of copper, so each 1% of grade earns about 10 × 0.88 × 9 ≈ US$79 per tonne. Break-even grade ≈ 15 ÷ 79 ≈ 0.19% Cu. Rock below about 0.2% goes to the waste dump. (Illustrative numbers only; real cut-offs include many more costs.)

Gold. 10 Mt at 2 g/t = 20,000,000 g = 20 tonnes of gold, or about 640,000 troy ounces (one troy ounce is ~31.1 g).

Try it · where does the ore end?

A cross-section through an imaginary copper deposit, cut into 200 blocks of about a million tonnes each. Grade is highest in the core and fades outward. Change the copper price, the cost of mining and processing a tonne, or the share of copper the mill recovers, and see which blocks are worth mining.

ground surface each block ≈ 1 million tonnes grade fades outward from the core
Ore: at or above the cut-offWaste (paler = lower grade)

Lower the price or raise the cost and the cut-off rises: the ore body shrinks to a richer core, while the same rock at the edge flips from ore to waste. Lower the cut-off and you gain tonnes but dilute the average grade. Simplified on purpose: every block that pays for itself is counted as ore, but a real mine must also strip waste rock to reach the ore, pay for the mine before it earns anything, and plan a pit shape that is safe to dig.

Plotting deposits by grade and tonnage on logarithmic axes reveals a trade-off. Some deposit types are small but rich, others vast but lean. A huge low-grade body can still hold more metal than a rich vein, and can be mined cheaply in bulk from an open pit. Over the past century the average grade of copper mined worldwide has fallen steadily, as the rich, easy deposits were used up and mining moved to bigger, leaner ones.

Try it · grade × tonnage = contained metal

Copper deposit types on a grade–tonnage plot (a schematic, not real data). Drag the orange point, or use the sliders, and watch the contained copper. Moving along a dashed diagonal keeps it the same.

1 kt Cu 10 kt Cu 100 kt Cu 1 Mt Cu 10 Mt Cu 100 Mt Cu Rich veins VMS Sediment-hosted Cu Porphyry Cu Too little metal:rarely worth mining 0.11101001,00010,000 Ore tonnage (million tonnes, log scale) 10%1%0.1% Copper grade (log scale)

Porphyries sit far below veins in grade but hold far more copper, because they are thousands of times larger. Each dashed diagonal holds ten times more copper than the one below it, because both axes are logarithmic: a step of ten along one axis cancels a step of ten back along the other. VMS (volcanogenic massive sulphide) and sediment-hosted copper are explained in Hydrothermal deposits and Sedimentary & surface deposits.

Source, transport, trap

How does nature achieve a 100× or 1,000× concentration? Every ore deposit, whatever its type, needs three things. This framework will organise the next three modules, so it is worth learning now.

  1. SourceA large volume of rock, magma or water that contains the metal, even at low levels.
  2. TransportSomething mobile that can pick the metal up and carry it: a magma, a hot watery fluid, groundwater or a river.
  3. TrapA place where conditions change suddenly, so the metal drops out of the carrier into a small volume.
ground surface reactive limestone layer ordinary country rock a little metal, spread thinly 1 2 3
  1. Source. A huge volume of magma, rock or water holding a little metal.
  2. Transport. Hot fluid (or magma) carries the metal up a fracture.
  3. Trap. Conditions change suddenly, and the metal drops out in a small volume.
The same three steps, at every scale. Here the source is a magma, the transport is hot water escaping from it, and the trap is a limestone layer that reacts with the fluid and forces the metal out of solution. A few cubic kilometres of source can feed a trap a thousand times smaller.
An ore deposit is not a place where metal was made. It is a place where metal was moved to, and then left behind.

A fourth ingredient is often added: preservation. Many deposits form close to the surface and are later eroded away. The deposits we find are the ones that were buried, tilted or protected long enough to survive. We return to this in Sedimentary & surface deposits.

Three families of deposit

Geologists classify deposits by the process that concentrated the metal, which really means by their transport agent and trap. Three broad families cover almost everything mined today.

Magma does the work

Magmatic

Metals crystallise or separate directly from cooling magma: chromite layers, nickel sulphides, diamonds carried up in kimberlite, lithium pegmatites.

CrNiPGELiREE
Hot water does the work

Hydrothermal

Hot, salty water dissolves metals and dumps them in veins and altered rock: porphyry copper, epithermal gold, seafloor black smokers.

CuAuZnPbMo
Surface processes do the work

Sedimentary & surface

Rivers, waves, weathering and evaporation sort and concentrate: gold placers, banded iron, bauxite, nickel laterite, lithium brines.

FeAlNiLiAu

Critical minerals and the energy transition

A critical mineral is one that an economy depends on and whose supply is at risk, for example because production is concentrated in a few countries. Lists differ by country, but the energy transition has put the same handful at the top of most of them. Electric vehicles, batteries, wind turbines and power grids all need far more metal than the fossil-fuel systems they replace. The International Energy Agency has estimated that a typical electric car needs roughly six times the mineral inputs of a conventional car, mostly in its battery and motor.

MineralMain energy-transition useMain deposit types
LithiumBattery cathodes and electrolytePegmatites (Australia); salt-lake brines (Chile, Argentina)
NickelBattery cathodes, stainless steelNickel laterites (Indonesia); magmatic sulphides
CobaltBattery cathodesSediment-hosted copper–cobalt (Central Africa); by-product of nickel
CopperWiring, motors, grids, chargingPorphyries; sediment-hosted copper
Rare earth elements (REE)Permanent magnets in EV motors and wind turbinesCarbonatites; ion-adsorption clays; monazite beach sands
GraphiteBattery anodesMetamorphosed organic-rich sediments; also made synthetically
Platinum-group elements (PGE)Catalysts, fuel cells, hydrogen electrolysersLayered intrusions (Bushveld); magmatic Ni–Cu sulphides (Norilsk)

Supply is lopsided. A single country often dominates mining or, even more often, refining of a given mineral. China refines most of the world's rare earths and graphite, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo mines most of its cobalt.

India published its first list of 30 critical minerals in 2023, including lithium, cobalt, nickel, graphite, copper, the rare earths and the platinum-group elements. The mining law was amended the same year so that the central government could auction exploration and mining rights for these minerals, and auctions of critical-mineral blocks have been running since late 2023. A state-backed company, KABIL, has also been securing lithium prospects overseas. All of this is creating demand for people who understand where these minerals come from, which is the subject of the next three modules, and how to find them, which is covered in Prospecting & the exploration pipeline.

Why this matters at Alt Earth

Alt Earth is expanding into mineral exploration alongside enhanced rock weathering, and this part of the course is the foundation for that work. The two share more than it might seem. Enhanced rock weathering treats rock as a feedstock, just as a mine does. The same toolkit applies to both: knowing which minerals are in a rock, in what proportions and grain sizes, and how they will react. A geologist who can characterise basalt for carbon removal is using the skills an exploration geologist uses on an ore.

The two worlds also meet physically. Mines that work mafic and ultramafic rocks, such as nickel, chromite and platinum mines, produce huge volumes of finely ground tailings rich in magnesium and calcium silicates. Those tailings have already been crushed, which is the expensive step, so they are actively studied as feedstocks for carbon removal.